The 2019 North Carolina 9th District Special Election will get more attention than the state’s other special this year.
In the 3rd District, also vacant, things are more stable for Republicans. This district, however, presents a bigger challenge for the GOP as they attempt to hold it — again.
This is the only of the 435 US House races from 2018 to remain undecided. A very close call on election night, Republican Mark Harris finished with a slim lead over Democrat Dan McCready. However, light was shed on on illegal absentee ballot tampering accusations against Leslie McCrae Dowless, a political operative. Dowless, it is said, had absentee ballots collected and then tampered with prior to delivery for counting; he was indicted earlier in 2019.
Though Harris himself denied any wrongdoing, the matter went before the state’s Board of Elections. Having previously refused to certify the final results, in the end, the board declared the 2018 vote invalid and a new election is to be held.
Update, May 14, 2019: Primary day in the 9th District was May 14. Because the Republican winner did so without need for a runoff, the special election will be held on September 10. Had this not been the case, the runoff would have been in September with the general election on November 5, the same day as Mississippi and Kentucky elect governors.
Check out notes on the field and our race prediction updates below. This was a featured race of ours during the 2018 election cycle.
2019 North Carolina 9th District Special Election: The District
The North Carolina 9th District includes part of the city of Charlotte in its westernmost point; a bit of the boundary jogs north towards downtown but stops just short. Many of Charlotte’s southeastern suburbs are included and then the 9th District runs about 130 miles along the South Carolina border. Towns and cities such as Lumberton, Wadesboro, and Laurinburg fall within its borders. Finally, to the northeast, the 9th District stretches up into Fayetteville, connecting with parts of the city.
What used to be the 9th District prior to court-ordered redistricting in 2016 stretched north from Charlotte. Another prior iteration of the district centered on the Charlotte suburbs, and was represented by Sue Myrick (R) for almost 20 years. Robert Pittenger (R) succeeded her for six years.
Charlie Cook’s PVI rates this as an R+8 district.
2019 North Carolina 9th District Special Election Results
Republican Dan Bishop was elected to Congress, winning a close race over Democrat Dan McCready.
2019 North Carolina 9th District Post-Election Analysis, September 11, 2019
As it turns out, our concerns over McCready’s lack of momentum were well-founded. He came up about two points short in the off-off year vote. While the Republicans got the “W,” both sides have something positive out of this election.
It is obvious what the Republicans took from this. They have not lost in this area in decades, and now is no exception. When some said they would lose, they found a slight uptick in their overall vote from the voided November election. Robeson County was a particular success story: this more rural Democratic county, including Lumberton, saw a spike in the GOP vote this time.
The Democrats had some good news, in that they were competitive a second time in a Republican-leaning district. North Carolina is a state of increasing importance on the federal level as well, so they will feel some hope there in general. If the Blue Wave has abated, it has not by much. This election was not a disaster for them, but for certain a disappointment.
2019 North Carolina 9th District Special Election: Analysis, August 7, 2019
The GOP got out of their primary without the need for a bruising runoff and have been forging ahead versus Dan McCready. Recent opinion polls suggest a close race, and not one that lends itself to sure things for either candidate. Given the overall lean of the district, this is not good news for McCready. What is also not positive for him is that McCready has been running for this seat uninterrupted for over two years now, did not win the 2018 election in a Democratic wave (and even if he might have save for the tampered ballots, it would have been a nail-biter), and can’t squeak out much better than a tie in the polls now. Putting it another way, we expected at this point to see McCready in a better spot.
With some caution, we are tipping this back into the Republican column.
2019 North Carolina 9th District Special Election: Analysis, March 30, 2019
Before you jump down our throats for calling this a Democratic gain, hear us out. First, the Republican primary will likely be bruising. Second, McCready has been running for this seat with almost no interruption for over a year and has no primary to face. Third, McCready came very close to winning last time, and the climate may not have changed all that much from the Democratic wave in November 2018.
This can, of course, change as one Republican emerges, but there is no telling who that will be. Also, how much help will they get from the GOP? They probably do not need to worry about the 3rd District, or the 12th District of Pennsylvania, but if they are using resources here, the Democrats will as well.
2019 North Carolina 9th District Special Election: Primary Results
State Senator Dan Bishop won the Republican primary on May 14. He captured 47.7 percent of the vote, giving him victory without a runoff. He defeated a field of nine other candidates, with Stony Rushing coming in a distant second.
Bishop carried every county in the district. In this comprehensive victory, he also won with election day voters, early voters, and absentee ballot voters.
Dan Bishop’s best county on primary night was Richmond, giving him 71 percent despite its low vote totals. Most of the primary votes were in Mecklenburg and Union Counties; Bishop claimed about 50 percent in Mecklenburg and 41.5 percent in Union.
A noted and vocal social conservative, Bishop’s claim to fame prior to this primary win was his involvement with North Carolina’s so-called “bathroom bill” as a sponsor. His State Senate district, the 39th, is within Mecklenburg County on the southeastern edge. He has been a state senator since 2017, after serving one term in the North Carolina House.
Bishop will face Dan McCready (D) in September.
2019 North Carolina 9th District Special Election: Last Time
Mark Harris took the final count on election night by a margin of 905 votes over Dan McCready. As discussed elsewhere, however, the validity of that victory was called into question immediately. The above election result was voided in early 2019.
Robert Pittenger won re-election with 58.2 percent of the vote in 2016.
2019 North Carolina 9th District Special Election: Candidates
March 15 was the last day for candidates to file for the May 14 primary. Ten Republicans jumped into the fray, though just two (Dan Bishop and Stony Rushing) are currently in public office. Several others have been in or run for office previously.
Harris, who scored an upset win over incumbent Robert Pittenger in the 2018 Republican primary and was at the center of the election scandal, is not running again. Dan McCready is, and he has not stopped running since the too-close-to-call election. He is the only Democratic candidate in the race against ther wide field of Republicans.
The Libertarians (Jeff Scott) and Green Party (Allen Smith) are also each running a candidate.
Pittenger also turned down a chance to run again in 2019.
2019 North Carolina 9th District Special Election: Current Prediction
This is a predicted Republican hold (1* – weak lean) as of August 7, 2019. This uses our proprietary Electionarium no-tossup scale of race ratings from 1* (weak lean) to 4* (very safe).